If you sell your property on seller financing, you must comply with Dodd Frank restrictions on seller financing. These restrictions apply if the deal is a recorded wrap-around deal. Some experts say that a lease option is not a sale and that Dodd Frank does not apply. Other experts say it does.

If you sell to a buyer who is not going live in the property, Dodd Frank does not apply. This means the seller can require full payoff in fewer than five years and that the interest rate may be variable from the start. It means that the buyer need not consult with a mortgage broker and qualify financially.

However, if you sell to a buyer who will live in the property, Dodd Frank does apply. Seller financed sales come under three exclusions.

One Property Exclusion: If you sell only one property per year, and if the buyer will live in the property, the buyer is not required to qualify through a mortgage broker. But the interest rate for the first five years must be fixed. Thereafter the rate and payment may increase. No negative amortization loans are allowed. The law probably allows a five year balloon payment cash out, although the law does not state this explicitly. It is clear that the rate can go up after five years to a level which will compel the buyer to refinance. Only sellers who are individuals, trusts, or estates can take advantage of the one property exclusion. Corporations, LLC’s, and partnerships cannot rely on the one-property exclusion.

Three Property Exclusion: If you sell to a buyer who will live in the property, and if you sell up to three properties per year, the buyer must qualify through a mortgage broker. The interest rate for the first five years again must be fixed. Thereafter the rate and payment again may increase. No negative amortization loans are allowed. It is clear under the three property rule that the seller must give the buyer a 30 year mortgage, but it is also clear that the rate can go up after five years to a level which would compel the buyer to refinance. Sellers who are individuals, trusts, estates, corporations, LLCs, and partnerships can use the three property exclusion.

Dodd Frank treats the seller who is not an individual but is a builder differently. But the law does not make it clear what extra requirement falls on the builder who engages in seller financing. Dodd Frank says neither the one-property, nor the three-property exclusions may be used, although the law does not make it clear what additional limitations there are and under what terms a seller can offer seller financing. Presumably, the same restrictions used under the three-party rule would apply where the seller is a builder and not an individual. Or perhaps builders are forbidden to engage in seller financing. The Dodd Frank statute does not make this clear one way or the other.

Dodd Frank treats the seller who sells more than three properties in a year differently. But the law does not make it clear what extra requirement falls on the seller who sells more than three properties per year. Neither the one-property, nor the three-property exclusions may be used, although the law does not make it clear what additional limitations there are and under what terms a seller can offer seller financing. Perhaps sellers who sell more than three properties in a year are forbidden to engage in seller financing. The Dodd Frank statute does not make this clear one way or the other.

To complicate matters further, there is the SAFE Act, which may overlap with with Dodd Frank. Read the Washington DFI explanation here. And you should also read this article by the DFI.

I repeat: Dodd Frank and the SAFE Act as they pertain to seller financing are poorly written. Consult an attorney and a mortgage broker if you are selling on seller financing and if the buyer is going to occupy the home. You should not rely on this overview for legal guidance since I have not completely figured out this conglomeration of semi-indecipherable provisions.

Read the Dodd Frank rules on seller financing:

http://www.consumerfinance.gov/eregulations/1026-36/2013-30108_20140118

Read the Washington regulations on seller financing:

http://www.dfi.wa.gov/documents/seller-financing/residential-seller-financing.pdf

Read the following items for more information. You will see there is quite a bit of divergent opinion as to how it applies to seller financing.

http://www.realtor.org/topics/seller-financing/the-safe-act

http://frascona.com/dodd-frank-consumer-financial-protection-owner-financing/

http://www.ksefocus.com/billdatabase/clientfiles/172/4/1720.pdf

https://www.biggerpockets.com/renewsblog/2014/01/17/dodd-frank-law-changes-seller-financing-investors/

http://www.legalwiz.com/owner-financing-dodd-frank-safe-act/

https://www.consumerfinance.gov/policy-compliance/rulemaking/final-rules/ability-repay-and-qualified-mortgage-standards-under-truth-lending-act-regulation-z/

http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_final-rule_ability-to-repay-interpretations.pdf

Click here to sign up for my email list.

James Robert Deal, Broker and Attorney
Broker with Agency One Realty LLC
WSBA # 8103, DOL # 39666
425-774-6611, 888-999-2022
James at James Deal dot com

James Robert Deal, Attorney & Broker

James Robert Deal, Attorney & Broker

Seeking Lease Option and Contract Sellers

Seeking Lease Option and Contract Sellers

Seeking Lease-Option and Seller Contract Sellers  Open Phone Line to Brokers, Buyers, Sellers 425-774-6611  -  888-999-2022 I am working with several buyers who have strong income and good down payments but who have bad credit and cannot get financing.  These buyers...

Blacks Against Mandatory Vaccination

Blacks Against Mandatory Vaccination

African-American community rages against manditory vaccination in California and the Tuskegee-like crimes of mandatory vaccines that destroy black babies' lives http://www.naturalnews.com/050038_SB277_vaccine_mandate_Tuskegee_medical_experiments_African-Americans.html...

Services We Offer

Services We Offer

We have an open telephone line to brokers, buyers, sellers, and clients in general who may need help with buying or selling real estate or who may need help with mortgage modification. Services we offer: Help to Brokers, Co-Brokering Escrow Setup Lease Option Deals...

Door-To-Door Transit

Door-To-Door Transit

Door-To-Door Transit: The Only Solution To Our Traffic Nightmare by James Robert Deal, Attorney Traffic is bad and getting worse, and there is no solution in sight, as one would conclude from reading Eli Sanders’  “Welcome to Town, Here’s Why You’re Stuck in Traffic”...

Seller Financing – The Original Financing

Seller Financing – The Original Financing

AN ABBREVIATED HISTORY OF CREATIVE FINANCING The first forms of financing was seller financing. The buyer would buy personal property or real property and pay the seller on an installment basis. Over time lending houses grew up, and purchase mortgages developed....

Lease-Option Deals Open Doors

Lease-Option Deals Open Doors

LEASE-OPTION AND LEASE PURCHASE DEALS A lease-option or lease-purchase deal is a form of seller financing.  With the lease-option deal, title stays in the seller until the buyer refinances or resells or otherwise pays off the seller. The wrap-around deed of trust deal...

Zombie Foreclosures

Zombie Foreclosures

CFPB: Zombie foreclosures hurt borrowers The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is keeping an eye on “zombie” foreclosures, which it worries cause “direct borrower harm,” according to a CFPB executive. Zombie foreclosures occur when a bank starts the foreclosure...

New Federal Rules on Foreclosure

New Federal Rules on Foreclosure

New Federal Rules on Foreclosure —By Erika Eichelberger - Thanks to Mother Jones On Thursday, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the federal consumer watchdog set up by the Dodd-Frank financial reform bill, announced a new set of foreclosure-prevention...

Washington MERS Suits Fail

Judges Dismiss MERS Suits By Evan Nemeroff Two borrower-initiated lawsuits alleging that the Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems role in the plaintiffs' deeds of trust caused them injury were both dismissed by federal judges in the Western District of Washington...

Modification on Rental

Modification on Rental

It is harder to get a mortgage modification on a rental property than it is on an owner occupied property. The rules are not as clear. You need a higher income to qualify for a rental modification because you have to be able to cover your home mortgage. Nevertheless,...

Making Home Affordable Continues

Making Home Affordable Continues

HAMP continues aiding borrowers Three firms still fall short in meeting servicing goals. Thanks to Housing Wire. Kerri Ann Panchuk December 9, 2013 4:48PM Bank of AmericaCitiTreasuryHome Affordable Modification ProgramHAMPhomeownersObama AdministrationHousing...

Rental Property Modification

Rental Property Modification

This is a rental property modification. Ocwen was the servicer, and the investor was Washington Mutual and now Chase. The owner quit paying for 20 months, and the balance rose to $254,000. The interest rate was already under 3.0%, because this was an adjustable rate...

Deceptive Practices in Foreclosures

Deceptive Practices in Foreclosures

Deceptive Practices in Foreclosures Thanks to the New York Times September 13, 2013  In early 2012 when five big banks settled with state and federal officials over widespread foreclosure abuses, flagrant violations — including the seizure of homes without due process...

Low Modification Approval Rate

Low Modification Approval Rate

This post comes from Martin Andelman. The low approval rate on modifications Martin discusses is the main reason why you should hire an attorney to do your modification. Our success rate on modifications is much higher, around 80%. Of course, part of the reason why...

Renters’ Rights in Foreclosure`

Renters’ Rights in Foreclosure`

Renters in Foreclosure: What Are Their Rights? Federal law gives important rights to tenants whose landlords have lost their properties through foreclosure. Renters and tenants are now being affected by foreclosures almost as often as homeowners. The financial...

Eminent Domain To Modify Loans

Eminent Domain To Modify Loans

A City Invokes Seizure Laws to Save Homes Peter DaSilva for The New York Times  Thanks to New York Times. Robert and Patricia Castillo paid $420,000 for a three-bedroom, one-bathroom home in Richmond, Calif., in 2005. It is now worth $125,000. By SHAILA DEWAN...

Lenders Lie to Modification Applicants

Lenders Lie to Modification Applicants

We have found that Lenders often take advantage of those who apply for modification on their own. Lenders tell them they have not received certain documents and say their documents have "expired". Often lenders  decline modification and do not make the reason clear....

Bank of America – Fannie Modification

Bank of America – Fannie Modification

HMH came to me following a financial hardship. He faced high payments on his Bank of America serviced loan, with a rate of 5.625. The investor is Fannie Mae. HMH is self-employed as a taxi driver. He also owns a rental house in Brooklyn, which breaks even or makes a...

Banks Forgive Mostly Worthless Seconds

Banks Forgive Mostly Worthless Seconds

The Second-Mortgage Shell Game By ELIZABETH M. LYNCH   Thanks to the New York Times IN January, federal regulators announced an $8.5 billion agreement with 10 mortgage servicers to settle claims of foreclosure abuses, including bungled loan modifications and the...

More Foreclosures Coming

Where is the housing market going in 2013? Thanks to CBS News   (MoneyWatch) The housing market in 2013 stands on a precipice. While there is hope that the slow, but real, housing recovery that took hold last year will continue, fear remains that a sudden...

Zombie Titles

The latest foreclosure horror: the zombie title By Michelle Conlin  Thanks to Reuters. COLUMBUS, Ohio | Thu Jan 10, 2013 1:58pm EST (Reuters) - Joseph Keller doesn't expect he'll live to see the end of 2013. He blames the house at 190 Avondale Avenue. Five years ago,...

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Guidelines

U.S. Consumer Watchdog to Issue Mortgage Rules By EDWARD WYATT Thanks to New York Times Published: January 10, 2013 WASHINGTON — Banks and other lenders will be prohibited from making home loans that offer deceptive teaser rates or require no documentation from...

Stratigic Default

Giving Up and Getting Out Foreclosures are no longer a last resort, and a growing percentage of americans think it’s ok to strategically default LISA IANNUCCI Years ago, homeowners viewed foreclosure as a last resort – after all other means had been exhausted to save...

Jumbo Modification

A residential property where the first loan was more than around $729,000 at the time of the default is not eligible for modification under the Making Home Affordable program. However, home owners with jumbo-size loans should not despair - especially if their home is...

What Caused the 2007 Crash

The Trillion Dollar Mistake That Triggered the Economic Meltdown Thanks to Martin Andelman It was summer, 2006, and Fed Chair Alan Greenspan had just raised interest rates for the 17th consecutive time in an effort to cool off the over-heated U.S. housing market....

Strategic Defaulters – To Jail With You

FHFA Looking to Jail Strategic Defaulters by my friend Martin Andelman   The Federal Housing Finance Administration (“FHFA”), which is the agency created to oversee Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac… the one run by perhaps the least popular man in America for his...

Still No Justice for Mortgage Abuses

Still No Justice for Mortgage Abuses September 1, 2012 Thanks to New York Times It has been six months since the big banks settled with state and federal officials over evidence of widespread foreclosure fraud, promising to provide $25 billion in mortgage relief in...

Successful Citi Modification

On this modification with Citi there was no principal reduction because the property was not underwater. However, the interest rate was reduced from 6.375% to 2.0% for five years, 3.0% for one year, and then 3.875% for the next 35 years. Read the details here:...

Midland Mortgage Modification

We negotiated a good deal for Dennis and his wife. They went from a 9.5% rate to 2.0% for five years, then 3.0% for a year, and 3.875% for the balance of the loan. They also got a $24,000 principal reduction. Read the details here:...

OCWEN – Principal Reductions – 2% Rate

OCWEN Principal Reduction: We negotiated a $93,000 principal reduction for this couple, provided they remain current on their payments for three years. The rate is 2.0% fixed for 25 years. Read the modification documents here:...

Misconceptions About Modifications

Read Richard Fonfrias on Seven Costly Misconceptions About Mortgage Loan Modifications: http://washingtonattorneybroker.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/richard-fonfrias-7-costly-misconceptions-about-mortgage-loan-modifications.pdf

Who is Liable on Business Credit Cards?

Business credit cards and the individual bankruptcy case by Cathy Moran, California Bankruptcy Lawyer Small corporations may have their names on the shareholder’s credit card, but likely are not actually liable for the charges made on the card.� Clients come with...

Happy Clients

I only post a quarter of the modifications we complete, and I have not posted any of them for some time.I will get caught up on that job when we get back from our road trip vacation. But I just have to post this letter from a client regarding a modification that is...

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive our latest news and updates.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This